| No. | Date | Season | Rd | Opponent | Venue | ||
| 467 | Blake | Haslam | 18/12/2021 | 2021/21 | 6 | Bayswater Park | Bayswater Park |
| 466 | Patrick | Grocott | 27/11/2021 | 2021/21 | 3 | Wonga Park | Warrandyte |
| 465 | Blake | Matheson | 20/11/2021 | 2021/21 | 2 | Templeton | Warrandyte |
| 464 | Tyson | Jaksic | 30/1/2021 | 2020/21 | 10 | Norwood | Norwood |
| 463 | Christopher | Rakuscek | 14/11/2020 | 2020/21 | 1 | Norwood | Warrandyte |
| 462 | Harry | Brown | 11/1/2020 | 2019/20 | 9 | Templeton | Templeton |
| 461 | Nuwan | Liyanapathirana | 5/10/2019 | 2019/20 | 1 | Norwood | Warrandyte |
| 460 | Lakshan | Madushanka | 5/10/2019 | 2019/20 | 1 | Norwood | Warrandyte |
| 459 | Lewis | Jaksic | 5/10/2019 | 2019/20 | 1 | Norwood | Warrandyte |
| 458 | Lachlan | McAlary | 5/10/2019 | 2019/20 | 1 | Norwood | Warrandyte |
| 457 | Stephen | Lockie | 26/1/2019 | 2018/19 | 12 | Chirnside Park | Chirnside Park |
| 456 | Michael | Burgess | 6/10/2018 | 2018/19 | 1 | Kilsyth | Warrandyte |
| 455 | Scott | Handley | 6/10/2018 | 2018/19 | 1 | Kilsyth | Warrandyte |
| 454 | Andrew | Wilgose | 24/2/2018 | 2017/18 | 14 | North Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 453 | Simon | Bowyer | 24/2/2018 | 2017/18 | 14 | North Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 452 | Bailey | Bowyer | 16/12/2017 | 2017/18 | 8 | Wantirna South | Wantirna South |
| 451 | Lloyd | Williams | 18/11/2017 | 2017/18 | 6 | South Croydon | Warrandyte |
| 450 | Sam | Lee | 11/11/2017 | 2017/18 | 5 | Montrose | Montrose |
| 449 | Brady | Poole | 8/1/2017 | 2016/17 | 7 | Warranwood | Warranwood |
| 448 | Darcy | Poole | 8/1/2017 | 2016/17 | 7 | Warranwood | Warranwood |
| 447 | Timothy | Nilsson | 10/12/2016 | 2016/17 | 6 | Wantirna South | Wantirna South |
| 446 | Josh.P | Aitken | 29/10/2016 | 2016/17 | 3 | Ainslie Park | Ainslie Park |
| 445 | Benjamin | Jackson | 8/10/2016 | 2016/17 | 1 | South Croydon | South Croydon |
| 444 | Neil | Brown | 14/11/2015 | 2015/16 | 4 | North Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 443 | Mark | Baker | 21/2/2015 | 2014/15 | 11 | Croydon Ranges | Warrandyte |
| 442 | Brenton | Styles | 18/10/2014 | 2014/15 | 2 | Lilydale | Lilydale |
| 441 | Luke | Killey | 4/10/2014 | 2014/15 | 1 | Montrose | Warrandyte |
| 440 | Lindsay | Gilbee | 11/1/2014 | 2013/14 | 7 | Lilydale | Lilydale |
| 439 | Daniel | Nilsson | 5/10/2013 | 2013/14 | 1 | Lilydale | Lilydale |
| 438 | Brandon | Stafford | 26/1/2013 | 2012/13 | 9 | East Ringwood | East Ringwood |
| 437 | Ben | McMellan | 19/1/2013 | 2012/13 | 8 | Eastfield | Warrandyte |
| 436 | Tim | Baker | 19/1/2013 | 2012/13 | 8 | Eastfield | Warrandyte |
| 435 | Nick | Taylor | 15/12/2012 | 2012/13 | 6 | Kilsyth | Warrandyte |
| 434 | Jolyon | Duffell | 1/12/2012 | 2012/13 | 5 | Croydon Ranges | Croydon Ranges |
| 433 | Ryan | Hoiberg | 17/11/2012 | 2012/13 | 4 | Montrose | Warrandyte |
| 432 | Tom | Ellis | 3/11/2012 | 2012/13 | 3 | St Andrews | St Andrews |
| 431 | Luke | Warren | 3/12/2011 | 2011/12 | 5 | Ainslie Park | Ainslie Park |
| 430 | Mitchell | Gaffney | 8/10/2011 | 2011/12 | 1 | Chirnside Park | Chirnside Park |
| 429 | Daniel | Barry | 22/1/2011 | 2010/11 | 9 | Warranwood | Warranwood |
| 428 | Ryan | Pascoe | 16/10/2010 | 2010/11 | 2 | Mooroolbark | Mooroolbark |
| 427 | Alex | McIntosh | 17/10/2009 | 2009/10 | 2 | St Andrews | Warrandyte |
| 426 | Stephen | Glenk | 3/10/2009 | 2009/10 | 1 | East Ringwood | East Ringwood |
| 425 | Brett | Montgomery | 3/10/2009 | 2009/10 | 1 | East Ringwood | East Ringwood |
| 424 | Dale | Lander | 20/12/2008 | 2008/09 | 9 | Lilydale | Warrandyte |
| 423 | Jack | Ellis | 29/11/2008 | 2008/09 | 7 | East Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 422 | Lee | Evans | 11/10/2008 | 2008/09 | 2 | Bayswater Park | Warrandyte |
| 421 | Clint | Thomas | 4/10/2008 | 2008/09 | 1 | Ainslie Park | Warrandyte |
| 420 | Cameron | Skermer | 4/10/2008 | 2008/09 | 1 | Ainslie Park | Warrandyte |
| 419 | Jake | Sherriff | 6/10/2007 | 2007/08 | 1 | Bayswater Park | Bayswater Park |
| 418 | Ben | Taylor | 27/1/2007 | 2006/07 | 12 | Montrose | Montrose |
| 417 | Timothy | Hookey | 20/1/2007 | 2006/07 | 11 | Norwood | Warrandyte |
| 416 | Danny | Cash | 18/11/2006 | 2006/07 | 6 | St Andrews | Warrandyte |
| 415 | Nami | Yilmaz | 7/10/2006 | 2006/07 | 1 | Bayswater Park | Warrandyte |
| 414 | Blake | Morgan | 7/10/2006 | 2006/07 | 1 | Bayswater Park | Warrandyte |
| 413 | Chris | Barry | 18/2/2006 | 2005/06 | 13 | Montrose | Montrose |
| 412 | Craig | Lincoln | 26/11/2005 | 2005/06 | 7 | Chirnside Park | Chirnside Park |
| 411 | Dave | Reed | 12/11/2005 | 2005/06 | 6 | St Andrews | St Andrews |
| 410 | Ayrton | Dehmel | 12/11/2005 | 2005/06 | 6 | St Andrews | St Andrews |
| 409 | Tyson | Rees | 8/10/2005 | 2005/06 | 2 | St Andrews | Warrandyte |
| 408 | Tyson | Walshe | 19/2/2005 | 2004/05 | 14 | Montrose | Montrose |
| 407 | Stuart | Haworth | 5/2/2005 | 2004/05 | 13 | Sth Croydon | Warrandyte |
| 406 | James | Logan | 11/12/2004 | 2004/05 | 8 | Norwood | Warrandyte |
| 405 | Justin | Cleaves | 27/11/2004 | 2004/05 | 7 | Croydon Ranges | Warrandyte |
| 404 | Marc | Centofanti | 2/10/2004 | 2004/05 | 1 | Croydon Ranges | Croydon Ranges |
| 403 | Charlie | Wright | 29/11/2003 | 2003/04 | 7 | Chirnside Park | Chirnside Park |
| 402 | Warren | Cottrell | 14/12/2002 | 2002/03 | 8 | Nth Ringwood | Nth Ringwood |
| 401 | Travis | Cauchi | 16/11/2002 | 2002/03 | 5 | Norwood | Warrandyte |
| 400 | Daniel | Wellesley | 2/11/2002 | 2002/03 | 4 | Bayswater Park | Bayswater Park |
| 399 | Graham | Aldred | 12/10/2002 | 2002/03 | 2 | Sth Warrandyte | Warrandyte |
| 398 | Cameron | Cloke | 9/2/2002 | 2001/02 | 13 | Sth Croydon | Sth Croydon |
| 397 | Matthew | Sazenis | 19/1/2002 | 2001/02 | 11 | St Andrews | Warrandyte |
| 396 | Rod | Bird | 20/10/2001 | 2001/02 | 3 | Nth Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 395 | Campbell | Holland | 2/12/2000 | 2000/01 | 5 | Ainslie Park | Ainslie Park |
| 394 | Jason | Cloke | 4/11/2000 | 2000/01 | 3 | Mooroolbark | Mooroolbark |
| 393 | Peter | Sharpe | 14/10/2000 | 2000/01 | 1 | Wonga Park | Warrandyte |
| 392 | Russell | Jenzen | 14/10/2000 | 2000/01 | 1 | Wonga Park | Warrandyte |
| 391 | Dean | Gidley | 26/2/2000 | 1999/00 | 11 | Ainslie Park | Warrandyte |
| 390 | Matthew | Gamble | 26/2/2000 | 1999/00 | 11 | Ainslie Park | Warrandyte |
| 389 | Andy | Gay | 20/2/1999 | 1998/99 | 11 | Wonga Park | Warrandyte |
| 388 | Matthew | Chapman | 20/2/1999 | 1998/99 | 11 | Wonga Park | Warrandyte |
| 387 | Andrew | Jarvis | 23/1/1999 | 1998/99 | 9 | Wantirna Sth | Wantirna Sth |
| 386 | Adam | White | 17/10/1998 | 1998/99 | 2 | Parkwood | Warrandyte |
| 385 | Adam | Beardall | 21/2/1998 | 1997/98 | 11 | Croydon Nth | Warrandyte |
| 384 | Tyson | Brent | 1/11/1997 | 1997/98 | 3 | Wantirna Sth | Warrandyte |
| 383 | Nigel | Peterson | 4/10/1997 | 1997/98 | 1 | Kilsyth | Kilsyth |
| 382 | Paul | Montgomery | 4/10/1997 | 1997/98 | 1 | Kilsyth | Kilsyth |
| 381 | Nick | Fazzolari | 4/10/1997 | 1997/98 | 1 | Kilsyth | Kilsyth |
| 380 | Stephen | Goddard | 22/2/1997 | 1996/97 | 11 | Wonga Park | Wonga Park |
| 379 | Stewart | Smead | 16/2/1997 | 1996/97 | 2 | Wantirna Sth | Wantirna Sth |
| 378 | Brendan | Barmby | 25/1/1997 | 1996/97 | 9 | Lilydale | Warrandyte |
| 377 | Shane | Baker | 14/12/1996 | 1996/97 | 7 | Ainslie Park | Warrandyte |
| 376 | Brad | Valentine | 16/11/1996 | 1996/97 | 5 | Norwood | Norwood |
| 375 | Richard | Webb | 26/10/1996 | 1996/97 | 3 | Nth Ringwood | Nth Ringwood |
| 374 | Chris | Bambury | 26/10/1996 | 1996/97 | 3 | Nth Ringwood | Nth Ringwood |
| 373 | Bruce | Ryan | 6/1/1996 | 1995/96 | 7 | Ainslie Park | Ainslie Park |
| 372 | Stewart | Rough | 16/12/1995 | 1995/96 | 6 | Mooroolbark | Mooroolbark |
| 371 | Justin | Edwards | 16/12/1995 | 1995/96 | 6 | Mooroolbark | Mooroolbark |
| 370 | Darren | Rose | 18/11/1995 | 1995/96 | 4 | Croydon Nth | Warrandyte |
| 369 | David | Tyrrell | 4/11/1995 | 1995/96 | 3 | St Andrews | St Andrews |
| 368 | Steve | Carroll | 12/11/1994 | 1994/95 | 4 | Mooroolbark | Mooroolbark |
| 367 | David | Stickels | 29/10/1994 | 1994/95 | 3 | Croydon Nth | Warrandyte |
| 366 | Nick | Brisbane | 29/10/1994 | 1994/95 | 3 | Croydon Nth | Warrandyte |
| 365 | Stephen | Warr | 12/2/1994 | 1993/94 | 10 | Ainslie Park | Warrandyte |
| 364 | Marcus | Doherty | 29/1/1994 | 1993/94 | 9 | Wonga Park | Wonga Park |
| 363 | Brett | Ratten | 8/1/1994 | 1993/94 | 7 | Croydon Nth | Croydon Nth |
| 362 | Rodney | Hogg | 2/10/1993 | 1993/94 | 1 | Norwood | Norwood |
| 361 | Michael | Canty | 16/1/1993 | 1992/93 | 8 | Croydon United | Croydon United |
| 360 | Stephen.J | Bell | 21/11/1992 | 1992/93 | 4 | Mooroolbark | Warrandyte |
| 359 | Campbell | Horlock | 24/10/1992 | 1992/93 | 2 | Ainslie Park | Ainslie Park |
| 358 | David | Harvey | 24/10/1992 | 1992/93 | 2 | Ainslie Park | Ainslie Park |
| 357 | Harry | Drysdale | 24/10/1992 | 1992/93 | 2 | Ainslie Park | Ainslie Park |
| 356 | David | Watts | 11/1/1992 | 1991/92 | 7 | Vermont | Warrandyte |
| 355 | David | Mooney | 30/11/1991 | 1991/92 | 5 | Ainslie Park | Ainslie Park |
| 354 | Greg | Creber | 16/11/1991 | 1991/92 | 4 | Lilydale | Warrandyte |
| 353 | Ben | Brisbane | 16/11/1991 | 1991/92 | 4 | Lilydale | Warrandyte |
| 352 | David | Booth | 2/2/1991 | 1990/91 | 9 | Norwood | Norwood |
| 351 | John | Sharman | 6/10/1990 | 1990/91 | 1 | Croydon United | Croydon United |
| 350 | Andrew | Hood | 6/10/1990 | 1990/91 | 1 | Croydon United | Croydon United |
| 349 | Mick | English | 6/10/1990 | 1990/91 | 1 | Croydon United | Croydon United |
| 348 | Darren | Carter | 6/10/1990 | 1990/91 | 1 | Croydon United | Croydon United |
| 347 | John | Barker | 6/10/1990 | 1990/91 | 1 | Croydon United | Croydon United |
| 346 | David | Jungwirth | 10/3/1990 | 1989/90 | 13 | Nth Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 345 | Andy.G | King | 29/1/1990 | 1989/90 | 11 | St Andrews | St Andrews |
| 344 | Paul | Hughes | 25/11/1989 | 1989/90 | 5 | Norwood | Warrandyte |
| 343 | Brendan | Baker | 4/11/1989 | 1989/90 | 4 | Ainslie Park | Warrandyte |
| 342 | Jason | Graf | 28/1/1989 | 1988/89 | 10 | Mt Evelyn | Mt Evelyn |
| 341 | Greg | Tregear | 1/10/1988 | 1988/89 | 1 | Mooroolbark | Mooroolbark |
| 340 | Andrew | Snaidero | 16/1/1988 | 1987/88 | 9 | Nth Ringwood | Nth Ringwood |
| 339 | Sean | Cameron | 9/1/1988 | 1987/88 | 8 | St Andrews | Warrandyte |
| 338 | David | Gee | 12/12/1987 | 1987/88 | 7 | Croydon Nth | Warrandyte |
| 337 | Dale | Vitiritti | 31/10/1987 | 1987/88 | 3 | Vermont | Vermont |
| 336 | Grant | Brisbane | 10/10/1987 | 1987/88 | 1 | Montrose | Warrandyte |
| 335 | Cameron | Day | 7/2/1987 | 1986/87 | 12 | Croydon Nth | Warrandyte |
| 334 | Michael | Day | 15/11/1986 | 1986/87 | 5 | Lilydale | Warrandyte |
| 333 | Jason | Kline | 11/10/1986 | 1986/87 | 2 | Croydon United | Croydon United |
| 332 | Tony | Sturesteps | 22/2/1986 | 1985/86 | 13 | Croydon Nth | Warrandyte |
| 331 | Chris | Snaidero | 30/11/1985 | 1985/86 | 6 | Wantirna Sth | Wantirna Sth |
| 330 | David | Sloan | 12/10/1985 | 1985/86 | 2 | Ainslie Park | Warrandyte |
| 329 | Russell | Dorning | 12/10/1985 | 1985/86 | 2 | Ainslie Park | Warrandyte |
| 328 | John | O'Brien | 9/2/1985 | 1984/85 | 12 | Ainslie Park | Ainslie Park |
| 327 | Mark | O'Brien | 15/12/1984 | 1984/85 | 7 | Mooroolbark | Mooroolbark |
| 326 | Reece | Kline | 15/12/1984 | 1984/85 | 7 | Mooroolbark | Mooroolbark |
| 325 | Matthew | Feather | 1/12/1984 | 1984/85 | 6 | Vermont | Warrandyte |
| 324 | Colin.P | Dorning | 11/2/1984 | 1983/84 | 12 | St Andrews | Warrandyte |
| 323 | Darren | Peters | 10/12/1983 | 1983/84 | 7 | Nth Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 322 | John | Salter | 1/10/1983 | 1983/84 | 1 | Wantirna | Wantirna |
| 321 | Graeme | Jacobs | 19/2/1983 | 1982/83 | 13 | St Andrews | Warrandyte |
| 320 | Gerald | Walshe | 5/2/1983 | 1982/83 | 12 | East Ringwood | East Ringwood |
| 319 | R | Thompson | 11/12/1982 | 1982/83 | 7 | Wonga Park | Wonga Park |
| 318 | Alan.C | King | 30/10/1982 | 1982/83 | 4 | Croydon United | Warrandyte |
| 317 | Brian | Scicluna | 9/10/1982 | 1982/83 | 2 | Wantirna | Warrandyte |
| 316 | Wayne | Amiguet | 2/10/1982 | 1982/83 | 1 | Wantirna Sth | Warrandyte |
| 315 | David | McDonald | 31/10/1981 | 1981/82 | 4 | Nth Ringwood | ? |
| 314 | Marty | McCarthy | 17/10/1981 | 1981/82 | 3 | Kilsyth | ? |
| 313 | Graeme | Lloyd | 10/10/1981 | 1981/82 | 2 | Croydon Nth | ? |
| 312 | Don | Turner | 17/1/1981 | 1980/81 | 9 | Wantirna Sth | Warrandyte |
| 311 | Peter | Leon | 29/11/1980 | 1980/81 | 6 | Croydon Nth | Warrandyte |
| 310 | Brett.R | Kline | 15/11/1980 | 1980/81 | 5 | Mooroolbark | Warrandyte |
| 309 | Paul | James | 11/10/1980 | 1980/81 | 2 | Wonga Park | Warrandyte |
| 308 | Dale | McCartin | 9/2/1980 | 1979/80 | 12 | Sth Warrandyte | Warrandyte |
| 307 | Joe | Peters | 5/1/1980 | 1979/80 | 8 | Ringwood Uniting | Kilsyth |
| 306 | Geoff.L | Taylor | 15/12/1979 | 1979/80 | 7 | Sth Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 305 | Wayne | Moore | 15/12/1979 | 1979/80 | 7 | Sth Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 304 | Bruce.A | Kline | 20/10/1979 | 1979/80 | 3 | Wantirna | Warrandyte |
| 303 | David | Johnson | 24/2/1979 | 1978/79 | 13 | Croydon Hockeyers | Croydon Hockeyers |
| 302 | Ian | Davies | 10/2/1979 | 1978/79 | 12 | Nth Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 301 | Stan | Davis | 6/1/1979 | 1978/79 | 8 | Sth Croydon | Sth Croydon |
| 300 | Neil | Davis | 6/1/1979 | 1978/79 | 8 | Sth Croydon | Sth Croydon |
| 299 | John | Pianta | 16/12/1978 | 1978/79 | 7 | Ringwood Uniting | Warrandyte |
| 298 | Barry.J | Johnson | 2/12/1978 | 1978/79 | 6 | Olinda | Olinda |
| 297 | John | McGrath | 4/11/1978 | 1978/79 | 4 | Ainslie Park | Ainslie Park |
| 296 | Stuart | Knight | 14/10/1978 | 1978/79 | 2 | Knoxfield | Knoxfield |
| 295 | Robert | Dunnett | 7/10/1978 | 1978/79 | 1 | Sth Warrandyte | Warrandyte |
| 294 | McGregor | Scott | 30/1/1978 | 1977/78 | 12 | Boronia United | Boronia United |
| 293 | David | Heywood | 7/1/1978 | 1977/78 | 9 | Ringwood Uniting | Warrandyte |
| 292 | Fred | Jungwirth | 29/10/1977 | 1977/78 | 5 | Sth Croydon | Sth Croydon |
| 291 | Geoff | Edwards | 8/10/1977 | 1977/78 | 2 | Olinda | Warrandyte |
| 290 | R | Roe | 1/10/1977 | 1977/78 | 1 | Bayswater Park | Bayswater Park |
| 289 | Brian | Chapman | 1/10/1977 | 1977/78 | 1 | Bayswater Park | Bayswater Park |
| 288 | Steve | Pascoe | 1/10/1977 | 1977/78 | 1 | Bayswater Park | Bayswater Park |
| 287 | Tony | Hulme | 5/2/1977 | 1976/77 | 10 | Bayswater Park | Bayswater Park |
| 286 | Peter | James | 11/12/1976 | 1976/77 | 7 | Ringwood RSL | Ringwood RSL |
| 285 | Richard | Bowen | 23/10/1976 | 1976/77 | 3 | Nth Ringwood | Nth Ringwood |
| 284 | Alan | Vitiritti | 2/10/1976 | 1976/77 | 1 | Croydon Nth | ? |
| 283 | Robert | McDonald | 24/1/1976 | 1975/76 | 8 | Lilydale | Warrandyte |
| 282 | Gary | Skinner | 22/2/1975 | 1974/75 | 10 | East Box Hill | Domeney Reserve |
| 281 | Ken | Cooper | 14/12/1974 | 1974/75 | 6 | Yarraleen | Yarraleen |
| 280 | Roy | Orme | 30/11/1974 | 1974/75 | 5 | Wattle Park | Domeney Reserve |
| 279 | Kevin | Jamieson | 30/11/1974 | 1974/75 | 5 | Wattle Park | Domeney Reserve |
| 278 | Peter | Emerson | 2/11/1974 | 1974/75 | 3 | Doncaster C.O.C. | Doncaster C.O.C. |
| 277 | Peter | Brown | 2/11/1974 | 1974/75 | 3 | Doncaster C.O.C. | Doncaster C.O.C. |
| 276 | John | Tuckwell | 19/10/1974 | 1974/75 | 2 | St Davids | Domeney Reserve |
| 275 | Graeme | Roberts | 19/10/1974 | 1974/75 | 2 | St Davids | Domeney Reserve |
| 274 | Stuart | Minetti | 5/10/1974 | 1974/75 | 1 | Burwood Socials | Hartwell Reserve |
| 273 | Ian | Broome | 5/10/1974 | 1974/75 | 1 | Burwood Socials | Hartwell Reserve |
| 272 | Neville | Craker | 23/2/1974 | 1973/74 | 10 | Doncaster Footballers | Warrandyte |
| 271 | Chris | Robotham | 9/2/1974 | 1973/74 | 9 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 270 | Max | Summers | 26/1/1974 | 1973/74 | 8 | East Burwood Methodists | Warrandyte |
| 269 | Theo | Grummisch | 26/1/1974 | 1973/74 | 8 | East Burwood Methodists | Warrandyte |
| 268 | Nick | Day | 26/1/1974 | 1973/74 | 8 | East Burwood Methodists | Warrandyte |
| 267 | Trevor | Craker | 22/12/1973 | 1973/74 | 6 | Burwood Socials | Warrandyte |
| 266 | Lionel | Price | 1/12/1973 | 1973/74 | 5 | Templestowe Footballers | Templestowe Footballers |
| 265 | K | Stanfield | 17/11/1973 | 1973/74 | 4 | St Marys | Warrandyte |
| 264 | Michael | Lovett | 17/11/1973 | 1973/74 | 4 | St Marys | Warrandyte |
| 263 | Rowan | McKenzie | 6/10/1973 | 1973/74 | 1 | Doncaster C.O.C. | Doncaster C.O.C. |
| 262 | John | McCartin | 6/10/1973 | 1973/74 | 1 | Doncaster C.O.C. | Doncaster C.O.C. |
| 261 | Alan | Ferguson | 6/10/1973 | 1973/74 | 1 | Doncaster C.O.C. | Doncaster C.O.C. |
| 260 | Brian | Cleaves | 6/10/1973 | 1973/74 | 1 | Doncaster C.O.C. | Doncaster C.O.C. |
| 259 | Warwick | Blair | 6/10/1973 | 1973/74 | 1 | Doncaster C.O.C. | Doncaster C.O.C. |
| 258 | Graham | Smith | 2/12/1972 | 1972/73 | 5 | Nunawading | Warrandyte |
| 257 | Linton | Smith | 4/11/1972 | 1972/73 | 3 | Blackburn | Warrandyte |
| 256 | Miraj | 30/10/1971 | 1971/72 | 3 | Bennettswood | Warrandyte | |
| 255 | Dennis | Jackson | 16/10/1971 | 1971/72 | 2 | Forest Hill | Warrandyte |
| 254 | Robert | White | 5/12/1970 | 1970/71 | 6 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 253 | Gary | Bensch | 5/12/1970 | 1970/71 | 6 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 252 | Glenn | Martin | 28/11/1970 | 1970/71 | 5 | E Bees | Warrandyte |
| 251 | Vince | Thornton | 31/10/1970 | 1970/71 | 3 | Forest Hill | Forest Hill |
| 250 | Alastair | Betley | 20/2/1970 | 1969/70 | 11 | Blackburn Nth | Blackburn Nth |
| 249 | Adrian | Newell | 13/12/1969 | 1969/70 | 6 | East Doncaster | Warrandyte |
| 248 | Dave | Urquhart | 29/11/1969 | 1969/70 | 5 | Yarraleen | Yarraleen |
| 247 | Graham | Betley | 15/11/1969 | 1969/70 | 4 | Box Hill C.O.C. | Box Hill C.O.C. |
| 246 | Alan | Woolcock | 4/10/1969 | 1969/70 | 1 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 245 | Ken | McKenzie | 1/2/1969 | 1968/69 | 8 | Doncaster Footballers | Warrandyte |
| 244 | Dennis | Murphy | 11/1/1969 | 1968/69 | 7 | Forest Hill | Warrandyte |
| 243 | Daryl | Valentine | 14/12/1968 | 1968/69 | 6 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 242 | Phillip | Thornton | 30/11/1968 | 1968/69 | 5 | Blackburn Nth | Warrandyte |
| 241 | Stephen | Peake | 5/10/1968 | 1968/69 | 1 | St Davids | Warrandyte |
| 240 | Sean | Hanrahan | 29/1/1968 | 1967/68 | 9 | Doncaster Footballers | Warrandyte |
| 239 | Gary | Deam | 29/1/1968 | 1967/68 | 9 | Doncaster Footballers | Warrandyte |
| 238 | Ian | World | 27/1/1968 | 1967/68 | 8 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 237 | Robert | Kuipers | 16/12/1967 | 1967/68 | 6 | Blackburn Nth | Warrandyte |
| 236 | Mark | Davis | 4/11/1967 | 1967/68 | 3 | Vermont | Vermont |
| 235 | John | Pepper | 7/10/1967 | 1967/68 | 1 | Adelphians | Warrandyte |
| 234 | Lloyd | Holyoak | 7/10/1967 | 1967/68 | 1 | Adelphians | Warrandyte |
| 233 | L | McGhee | 30/1/1967 | 1966/67 | 9 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 232 | Alan | Frowd | 14/1/1967 | 1966/67 | 7 | St Lukes | St Lukes |
| 231 | Michael | Hanrahan | 26/11/1966 | 1966/67 | 5 | Blackburn Nth | Blackburn Nth |
| 230 | John | Pridmore | 19/11/1966 | 1966/67 | 4 | Adelphians | Adelphians |
| 229 | Lindsay | Bellinger | 1/10/1966 | 1966/67 | 1 | Nunawading | Nunawading |
| 228 | Geoff | Anderson | 1/10/1966 | 1966/67 | 1 | Nunawading | Nunawading |
| 227 | Stephen | Wilson | 22/1/1966 | 1965/66 | 8 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 226 | Adrian | Prince | 22/1/1966 | 1965/66 | 8 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 225 | Alan | Bellinger | 30/10/1965 | 1965/66 | 3 | Nunawading | Warrandyte |
| 224 | Ian | Prior | 16/10/1965 | 1965/66 | 2 | Adelphians | Warrandyte |
| 223 | Kase | Merbis | 16/10/1965 | 1965/66 | 2 | Adelphians | Warrandyte |
| 222 | Toby | Thomas | 2/10/1965 | 1965/66 | 1 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 221 | Tim | Smith | 20/2/1965 | 1964/65 | 10 | Bulleen | Bulleen |
| 220 | Alan | Rowell | 12/12/1964 | 1964/65 | 6 | Mitcham | Donvale |
| 219 | John | Chapman | 31/10/1964 | 1964/65 | 3 | St Peters | St Peters |
| 218 | Robert | Anderson | 3/10/1964 | 1964/65 | 1 | Bulleen | Bulleen |
| 217 | R | Bowen | 8/2/1964 | 1963/64 | 9 | Vermont | Vermont |
| 216 | Roger | Craig | 25/1/1964 | 1963/64 | 8 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 215 | Laurie | Warr | 5/10/1963 | 1963/64 | 1 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 214 | Ross | Hurwood | 5/10/1963 | 1963/64 | 1 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 213 | Peter | Sparkes | 9/2/1963 | 1962/63 | 10 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 212 | I | Reid | 26/1/1963 | 1962/63 | 9 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 211 | Eddie | Nylander | 20/10/1962 | 1962/63 | 2 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 210 | Peter | Adams | 6/10/1962 | 1962/63 | 1 | Meadows | Meadows |
| 209 | Ken | Sergeant | 20/1/1962 | 1961/62 | 8 | Mitcham | Warrandyte |
| 208 | Brian | Thomas | 4/2/1961 | 1960/61 | 9 | Blackburn | Warrandyte |
| 207 | Albert | Prior | 10/12/1960 | 1960/61 | 6 | Mitcham | Warrandyte |
| 206 | John | Savige | 29/10/1960 | 1960/61 | 3 | St Peters | Warrandyte |
| 205 | Barry | Leheny | 29/10/1960 | 1960/61 | 3 | St Peters | Warrandyte |
| 204 | Frank | Schubert | 1/10/1960 | 1960/61 | 1 | Nunawading | Nunawading |
| 203 | Gordon | Page | 1/10/1960 | 1960/61 | 1 | Nunawading | Nunawading |
| 202 | Gary | McDonough | 1/10/1960 | 1960/61 | 1 | Nunawading | Nunawading |
| 201 | Kevin | Luttick | 1/10/1960 | 1960/61 | 1 | Nunawading | Nunawading |
| 200 | David | Dickson | 1/10/1960 | 1960/61 | 1 | Nunawading | Nunawading |
| 199 | Ray | Bellinger | 1/10/1960 | 1960/61 | 1 | Nunawading | Nunawading |
| 198 | Geoff | Day | 3/10/1959 | 1959/60 | 1 | East Burwood | ? |
| 197 | Brendan | Cassidy | 3/10/1959 | 1959/60 | 1 | East Burwood | ? |
| 196 | Ray | Girling | 30/11/1957 | 1957/58 | 5 | Templestowe | ? |
| 195 | K | Rumble | 30/11/1957 | 1957/58 | 5 | Templestowe | ? |
| 194 | Norm | Stewart | 30/11/1957 | 1957/58 | 5 | Templestowe | ? |
| 193 | Bruce | McAuley | 30/11/1957 | 1957/58 | 5 | Templestowe | ? |
| 192 | Edward | Cornish | 12/1/1957 | 1956/57 | 7 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 191 | Trevor | Pike | 1/12/1956 | 1956/57 | 5 | East Burwood | Warrandyte |
| 190 | Alby | Padley | 20/10/1956 | 1956/57 | 2 | Box Hill Footballers | Warrandyte |
| 189 | Les | Stoneham | 6/10/1956 | 1956/57 | 1 | Box Hill C.O.C. | Box Hill C.O.C. |
| 188 | Doug | Fry | 3/12/1955 | 1955/56 | 5 | Canterbury Socials | Warrandyte |
| 187 | Stan | Craker | 3/12/1955 | 1955/56 | 6 | Canterbury Socials | Warrandyte |
| 186 | E | Dickason | 19/11/1955 | 1955/56 | 5 | St Peters | U |
| 185 | Don | Chapman | 3/12/1955 | 1955/56 | 5 | Canterbury Socials | Warrandyte |
| 184 | Rod | McAuley | 11/12/1954 | 1954/55 | 6 | Doncaster Footballers | Doncaster Footballers |
| 183 | John | Smith | 16/10/1954 | 1954/55 | 2 | East Burwood | East Burwood |
| 182 | John | Holland | 2/10/1954 | 1954/55 | 1 | Canterbury Socials | Warrandyte |
| 181 | A | Dove | 5/12/1953 | 1953/54 | 6 | Box Hill C.O.C. | Warrandyte |
| 180 | Graham | Davidson | 5/12/1953 | 1953/54 | 6 | Box Hill C.O.C. | Warrandyte |
| 179 | Dave | Symons | 24/10/1953 | 1953/54 | 3 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 178 | A | McDougall | 29/11/1952 | 1952/53 | 5 | Blackburn | Warrandyte |
| 177 | John | Bradbury | 15/11/1952 | 1952/53 | 4 | C.Y.M.S. | Warrandyte |
| 176 | W | Eldridge | 18/10/1952 | 1952/53 | 2 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 175 | Morrie | Bennett | 23/2/1952 | 1951/52 | 10 | St.Peters | St.Peters |
| 174 | P | Moore | 26/1/1952 | 1951/52 | 8 | Box Hill C.O.C. | Box Hill C.O.C. |
| 173 | B | Miller | 6/10/1951 | 1951/52 | 1 | St Peters | U |
| 172 | William | Morrison | 3/2/1951 | 1950/51 | 9 | Meadows | U |
| 171 | B | Oram | 20/1/1951 | 1950/51 | 8 | Doncaster Triangle | U |
| 170 | P | Coltman | 20/1/1951 | 1950/51 | 8 | Doncaster Triangle | U |
| 169 | J | Benson | 6/1/1951 | 1950/51 | 7 | East Doncaster | U |
| 168 | Frank | Pike | 4/11/1950 | 1950/51 | 3 | Doncaster Footballers | Doncaster |
| 167 | Brian | Fry | 4/11/1950 | 1950/51 | 3 | Doncaster Footballers | Doncaster |
| 166 | Keith | Shields | 14/10/1950 | 1950/51 | 1 | Surrey Y.C.W. | ? |
| 165 | Jim | Harris | 14/10/1950 | 1950/51 | 1 | Surrey Y.C.W. | ? |
| 164 | Horace Jnr | Smith | 27/3/1948 | 1947/48 | GF | Y.C.W. | Kilsyth |
| 163 | Colin | Chapman | 10/1/1948 | 1947/48 | 7 | Boronia | Boronia |
| 162 | Jim | Lee | 8/11/1947 | 1947/48 | 3 | Croydon | Warrandyte |
| 161 | William | Aumann | 16/11/1946 | 1946/47 | 3 | Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 160 | Stan | Houghton | 12/10/1946 | 1946/47 | 1 | Nth Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 159 | Terry | Leheny | 26/1/1946 | 1945/46 | 8 | Sth Warrandyte | Sth Warrandyte |
| 158 | Strudwick | 5/1/1946 | 1945/46 | 7 | East Ringwood | East Ringwood | |
| 157 | H | Hodgson | 1/12/1945 | 1945/46 | 5 | Scoresby | Warrandyte |
| 156 | Clive | Smith | 3/11/1945 | 1945/46 | 3 | Boronia | Warrandyte |
| 155 | D | Bishop | 6/10/1945 | 1945/46 | 1 | Sth Warrandyte | Warrandyte |
| 154 | Arthur.S | Chapman | 21/12/1940 | 1940/41 | 6 | Ferntree Gully | Warrandyte |
| 153 | W | Wagner | 4/3/1939 | 1938/39 | 11 | Ringwood | Ringwood |
| 152 | Adrian | Chapman | 4/3/1939 | 1938/39 | 11 | Ringwood | Ringwood |
| 151 | Ethelbert | Crawshaw | 21/1/1939 | 1938/39 | 8 | Montrose | Warrandyte |
| 150 | William | Knee | 29/10/1938 | 1938/39 | 3 | Nth Ringwood | Nth Ringwood |
| 149 | Les | Adams | 29/10/1938 | 1938/39 | 3 | Nth Ringwood | Nth Ringwood |
| 148 | E | Stewart | 1/10/1938 | 1938/39 | 1 | Wonga Park | Wonga Park |
| 147 | Allan.E | Chapman | 1/10/1938 | 1938/39 | 1 | Wonga Park | Wonga Park |
| 146 | G | McIlwraith | 27/11/1937 | 1937/38 | 5 | Boronia | Warrandyte |
| 145 | S | Neale | 13/2/1937 | 1936/37 | 9 | Wantirna | Wantirna |
| 144 | William | Shea | 23/1/1937 | 1936/37 | 7 | Bayswater | Warrandyte |
| 143 | R | Stevens | 17/10/1936 | 1936/37 | 2 | C.Y.M.S. | Warrandyte |
| 142 | Fred | Carleton | 3/10/1936 | 1936/37 | 1 | Sth Warrandyte | Sth Warrandyte |
| 141 | Lindsay | Allan | 7/3/1936 | 1935/36 | 11 | Ringwood | Warrandyte |
| 140 | J | Wagner | 19/10/1935 | 1935/36 | 2 | Ringwood | Ringwood |
| 139 | E | Millson | 5/10/1935 | 1935/36 | 1 | Wonga Park | Warrandyte |
| 138 | D | Houghton | 5/10/1935 | 1935/36 | 1 | Wonga Park | Warrandyte |
| 137 | George | Spruzen | 9/2/1935 | 1934/35 | 9 | Box Hill Methodists | Warrandyte |
| 136 | R | O'Brien | 20/10/1934 | 1934/35 | 2 | Mont Albert | Mont Albert |
| 135 | Richard | Leheny | 20/10/1934 | 1934/35 | 2 | Mont Albert | Mont Albert |
| 134 | Ron | Brady | 20/10/1934 | 1934/35 | 2 | Mont Albert | Mont Albert |
| 133 | J | Keen | 17/2/1934 | 1933/34 | 10 | Bayswater | Bayswater |
| 132 | D | Reid | 27/1/1934 | 1933/34 | 8 | Kilsyth | Kilsyth |
| 131 | Ralph | McAuley | 28/10/1933 | 1933/34 | 3 | Boronia | Boronia |
| 130 | Fred | Craker | 28/10/1933 | 1933/34 | 3 | Boronia | Boronia |
| 129 | Geoff | Taylor | 30/9/1933 | 1933/34 | 1 | Croydon | Croydon |
| 128 | W | Robinson | 30/9/1933 | 1933/34 | 1 | Croydon | Croydon |
| 127 | Jim | Heitsch | 30/9/1933 | 1933/34 | 1 | Croydon | Croydon |
| 126 | Sydney | Houghton | 5/11/1932 | 1932/33 | 3 | Centrals | Centrals |
| 125 | J | Egan | 5/11/1932 | 1932/33 | 3 | Centrals | Centrals |
| 124 | S | Till | 1/10/1932 | 1932/33 | 1 | Wonga Park | Wonga Park |
| 123 | H | Miller | 1/10/1932 | 1932/33 | 1 | Wonga Park | Wonga Park |
| 122 | C | McKenzie | 1/10/1932 | 1932/33 | 1 | Wonga Park | Wonga Park |
| 121 | J | Huxley | 1/10/1932 | 1932/33 | 1 | Wonga Park | Wonga Park |
| 120 | E | English | 1/10/1932 | 1932/33 | 1 | Wonga Park | Wonga Park |
| 119 | Joseph | Dunkling | 1/10/1932 | 1932/33 | 1 | Wonga Park | Wonga Park |
| 118 | N | Thompson | 9/1/1932 | 1931/32 | 7 | Returned Soldiers | Warrandyte |
| 117 | W | Harding | 3/10/1931 | 1931/32 | 1 | Surrey Hills | Warrandyte |
| 116 | Charles | Fellows | 3/10/1931 | 1931/32 | 1 | Surrey Hills | Warrandyte |
| 115 | Roy | Mitchell | 27/9/1930 | 1930/31 | 1 | Vermont | Vermont |
| 114 | T | White | 19/10/1929 | 1929/30 | 2 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 113 | Len | Retchford | 19/10/1929 | 1929/30 | 2 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 112 | George | Smith | 5/10/1929 | 1929/30 | 1 | Surrey Hills Methodists | Warrandyte |
| 111 | William | Hemsworth | 5/10/1929 | 1929/30 | 1 | Surrey Hills Methodists | Warrandyte |
| 110 | Cecil | Houghton | 2/2/1929 | 1928/29 | 9 | Surrey Hills | Surrey Hills |
| 109 | William | McAuley | 3/11/1928 | 1928/29 | 3 | Box Hill | Warrandyte |
| 108 | T | Woolley | 13/10/1928 | 1928/29 | 2 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 107 | Norm | Smith | 13/10/1928 | 1928/29 | 2 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 106 | Edward | Hemsworth | 13/10/1928 | 1928/29 | 2 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 105 | Frank | Adams | 13/10/1928 | 1928/29 | 2 | Mitcham | Mitcham |
| 104 | R | Smith | 11/2/1928 | 1927/28 | 9 | Surrey Hills | Warrandyte |
| 103 | Edward | Kitchenham | 5/11/1927 | 1927/28 | 3 | Blackburn | Warrandyte |
| 102 | E | White | 11/12/1926 | 1926/27 | 6 | Wattles | Wattles |
| 101 | John Jnr | Moore | 27/11/1926 | 1926/27 | 5 | Mitcham | Warrandyte |
| 100 | John | Hutchinson | 30/10/1926 | 1926/27 | 3 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 99 | Fred | Russell | 16/10/1926 | 1926/27 | 2 | Box Hill A.N.A. | Warrandyte |
| 98 | Henie | Robinson | 2/10/1926 | 1926/27 | 1 | Box Hill | Warrandyte |
| 97 | Horace Snr | Smith | 28/11/1925 | 1925/26 | 5 | St Andrews | St Andrews |
| 96 | H | Paul | 3/10/1925 | 1925/26 | 1 | Box Hill | Box Hill |
| 95 | Edward | Houghton | 3/10/1925 | 1925/26 | 1 | Box Hill | Box Hill |
| 94 | B | Cavanagh | 21/2/1925 | 1924/25 | 9 | Canterbury | Warrandyte |
| 93 | Alan | Houghton | 2/2/1924 | 1923/24 | 8 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 92 | G | Dillon | 1/12/1923 | 1923/24 | 5 | East Doncaster | Warrandyte |
| 91 | George | White | 20/10/1923 | 1923/24 | 2 | Doncaster Heights | Doncaster Heights |
| 90 | William | Edyvane | 21/10/1922 | 1922/23 | 2 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 89 | T | Swann | 7/10/1922 | 1922/23 | 1 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 88 | W | Boyle | 7/10/1922 | 1922/23 | 1 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 87 | Jack | McAuley | 21/1/1922 | 1921/22 | 7 | Box Hill | Box Hill |
| 86 | G | Davis | 21/1/1922 | 1921/22 | 7 | Box Hill | Box Hill |
| 85 | Arthur | Hussey | 8/10/1921 | 1921/22 | 1 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 84 | Len | Belzer | 27/11/1920 | 1920/21 | 5 | Box Hill | Box Hill |
| 83 | A | Smith | 31/1/1920 | 1919/20 | 8 | Doncaster Heights | Warrandyte |
| 82 | Frank | Houghton | 6/12/1919 | 1919/20 | 5 | Doncaster Juniors | Warrandyte |
| 81 | David | Colman | 6/12/1919 | 1919/20 | 5 | Doncaster Juniors | Warrandyte |
| 80 | Oswald | Aumann | 22/11/1919 | 1919/20 | 4 | East Doncaster | East Doncaster |
| 79 | James | Schubert | 11/10/1919 | 1919/20 | 1 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 78 | H | Neale | 11/10/1919 | 1919/20 | 1 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 77 | John | Moore | 11/10/1919 | 1919/20 | 1 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 76 | S | Edmonds | 11/10/1919 | 1919/20 | 1 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 75 | G | Cameron | 12/1/1918 | 1917/18 | 7 | Doncaster | Doncaster |
| 74 | Ernest | Aumann | 12/1/1918 | 1917/18 | 7 | Doncaster | Doncaster |
| 73 | J | Tisdale | 20/10/1917 | 1917/18 | 2 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 72 | V | Johnson | 20/10/1917 | 1917/18 | 2 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 71 | H | Crouch | 20/10/1917 | 1917/18 | 2 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 70 | J | Fithie | 3/3/1917 | 1916/17 | 10 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 69 | Robert | Budge | 3/3/1917 | 1916/17 | 10 | Blackburn | Blackburn |
| 68 | William | Broussard | 17/2/1917 | 1916/17 | 9 | Box Hill | Box Hill |
| 67 | Price | 13/1/1917 | 1916/17 | 6 | Canterbury | Canterbury | |
| 66 | R | Everon | 13/1/1917 | 1916/17 | 6 | Canterbury | Canterbury |
| 65 | William | McCulloch | 25/11/1916 | 1916/17 | 4 | Box Hill | Warrandyte |
| 64 | Art | Budge | 25/11/1916 | 1916/17 | 4 | Box Hill | Warrandyte |
| 63 | N | Schneider | 20/11/1915 | 1915/16 | 4 | Croydon | Croydon |
| 62 | Eric | Sloan | 6/11/1915 | 1915/16 | 3 | Vermont | Vermont |
| 61 | Jack | White | 9/10/1915 | 1915/16 | 1 | East Doncaster | East Doncaster |
| 60 | Frank | Sloan | 20/3/1915 | 1914/15 | 12 | Vermont | Vermont |
| 59 | J | Hardridge | 6/2/1915 | 1914/15 | 9 | Doncaster Heights | Doncaster Heights |
| 58 | Alfred | Squires | 7/11/1914 | 1914/15 | 3 | Ferntree Gully | Ferntree Gully |
| 57 | Albert | Forden | 7/11/1914 | 1914/15 | 3 | Ferntree Gully | Ferntree Gully |
| 56 | Ron | Belzer | 24/1/1914 | 1913/14 | 8 | Wonga Park | Warrandyte |
| 55 | Edwin | Holloway | 29/11/1913 | 1913/14 | 5 | East Doncaster | East Doncaster |
| 54 | George | Houghton | 18/10/1913 | 1913/14 | 2 | Doncaster Heights | Warrandyte |
| 53 | G | Mansfield | 26/10/1912 | 1912/13 | 2 | Koonung | Koonung |
| 52 | William | Colman | 19/10/1912 | 1912/13 | 2 | Koonung | Koonung |
| 51 | P | Prendergast | 5/10/1912 | 1912/13 | 1 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 50 | James | Leheny | 21/10/1911 | 1911/12 | 2 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 49 | H | Marsh | 7/10/1911 | 1911/12 | 1 | Doncaster Ramblers | Warrandyte |
| 48 | G | Clark | 7/10/1911 | 1911/12 | 1 | Doncaster Ramblers | Warrandyte |
| 47 | J | Brooks | 7/10/1911 | 1911/12 | 1 | Doncaster Ramblers | Warrandyte |
| 46 | J | Torode | 10/12/1910 | 1910/11 | 6 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 45 | Henry Jnr | Stiggants | 10/12/1910 | 1910/11 | 6 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 44 | Les | McCulloch | 26/11/1910 | 1910/11 | 5 | Koonung | Koonung |
| 43 | Conrad | Schultz | 8/10/1910 | 1910/11 | 1 | Mooroolbark | Mooroolbark |
| 42 | Jack | Colman | 11/12/1909 | 1909/10 | 4 | Templestowe | Warrandyte |
| 41 | Leonard | Turnley | 20/11/1909 | 1909/10 | 3 | Doncaster Heights | Warrandyte |
| 40 | F | Johnson | 20/11/1909 | 1909/10 | 3 | Doncaster Heights | Warrandyte |
| 39 | H | Webb | 9/10/1909 | 1909/10 | 1 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 38 | Thomas | Schubert | 9/10/1909 | 1909/10 | 1 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 37 | Richard | McCulloch | 9/10/1909 | 1909/10 | 1 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 36 | H | Johnson | 9/10/1909 | 1909/10 | 1 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 35 | T | Bartley | 9/10/1909 | 1909/10 | 1 | Templestowe | Templestowe |
| 34 | Sam | McAuley | 27/3/1909 | 1908/09 | 9 | St Barnabas | St Barnabas |
| 33 | Archibald | Forden | 12/12/1908 | 1908/09 | 4 | St Barnabas | St Barnabas |
| 32 | William | Till | 31/10/1908 | 1908/09 | 2 | Blackburn | Warrandyte |
| 31 | A | Green | 31/10/1908 | 1908/09 | 2 | Blackburn | Warrandyte |
| 30 | George | Speers | 17/10/1908 | 1908/09 | 1 | Canterbury Methodists | Mitcham |
| 29 | John | Speers | 12/1/1907 | 1906/07 | 5 | Yarra Glen | Yarra Glen |
| 28 | William | Moore | 12/1/1907 | 1906/07 | 5 | Yarra Glen | Yarra Glen |
| 27 | J | Smith | 1/12/1906 | 1906/07 | 3 | Kinglake | Queenstown |
| 26 | T | Landrigan | 24/11/1906 | 1906/07 | 2 | Panton Hill | Panton Hill |
| 25 | Fred | Topping | 20/10/1906 | 1906/07 | 1 | Yarra Glen | Warrandyte |
| 24 | A | Soper | 20/10/1906 | 1906/07 | 1 | Yarra Glen | Warrandyte |
| 23 | F | Livy | 20/10/1906 | 1906/07 | 1 | Yarra Glen | Warrandyte |
| 22 | H | Ives | 20/10/1906 | 1906/07 | 1 | Yarra Glen | Warrandyte |
| 21 | Henry | Gearing | 20/10/1906 | 1906/07 | 1 | Yarra Glen | Warrandyte |
| 20 | Thomas | Crymble | 20/10/1906 | 1906/07 | 1 | Yarra Glen | Warrandyte |
| 19 | Les | Till | 26/5/1906 | 1905/06 | SF | Christmas Hills | Panton Hill |
| 18 | Davidson | 17/3/1906 | 1905/06 | 8 | Caledonia | Queenstown | |
| 17 | Jim | Bennie | 10/2/1906 | 1905/06 | 6 | Christmas Hills | Christmas Hills |
| 16 | John | Meares | 27/1/1906 | 1905/06 | 5 | Panton Hill | Panton Hill |
| 15 | R | Logan | 27/1/1906 | 1905/06 | 5 | Panton Hill | Panton Hill |
| 14 | Tim | Bennie | 27/1/1906 | 1905/06 | 5 | Panton Hill | Panton Hill |
| 13 | Albert | Stiggants | 16/12/1905 | 1905/06 | 3 | Caledonia | Warrandyte |
| 12 | R | Mahoney | 16/12/1905 | 1905/06 | 3 | Caledonia | Warrandyte |
| 11 | George | Quick | 2/12/1905 | 1905/06 | 2 | Kangaroo Ground | Kangaroo Ground |
| 10 | A | Nunwick | 2/12/1905 | 1905/06 | 2 | Kangaroo Ground | Kangaroo Ground |
| 9 | Edward | Kruse | 2/12/1905 | 1905/06 | 2 | Kangaroo Ground | Kangaroo Ground |
| 8 | Fred | Gould | 2/12/1905 | 1905/06 | 2 | Kangaroo Ground | Kangaroo Ground |
| 7 | James | Forden | 2/12/1905 | 1905/06 | 2 | Kangaroo Ground | Kangaroo Ground |
| 6 | George | Wyatt | 18/11/1905 | 1905/06 | 1 | Christmas Hills | Warrandyte |
| 5 | C | Sanford | 18/11/1905 | 1905/06 | 1 | Christmas Hills | Warrandyte |
| 4 | J | Hodgson | 18/11/1905 | 1905/06 | 1 | Christmas Hills | Warrandyte |
| 3 | Herbert | Forden | 18/11/1905 | 1905/06 | 1 | Christmas Hills | Warrandyte |
| 2 | Alf | Bennie | 18/11/1905 | 1905/06 | 1 | Christmas Hills | Warrandyte |
| 1 | John | Till | 18/11/1905 | 1905/06 | 1 | Christmas Hills | Warrandyte |
