| Player | Date | Team | Season | Round | Grade | Opponent | Opp Team | Venue |
| J Hodgson | 9/02/1907 | 1st XI | 1906/07 | R07 | A Grade | Panton Hill | 1st XI | Warrandyte #1 |
| William Colman | 11/03/1916 | 1st XI | 1915/16 | SF | B Grade | East Doncaster | 1st XI | East Doncaster |
| Les McCulloch | 2/02/1924 | 1st XI | 1923/24 | R08 | B1 Grade | Blackburn | 3rd XI | Blackburn |
| James Schubert | 2/10/1926 | 1st XI | 1926/27 | R01 | B Grade | Box Hill | 2nd XI | Warrandyte #1 |
| William Moore | 4/12/1926 | 2nd XI | 1926/27 | R05 | C Grade | Blackburn | 3rd XI | Blackburn |
| Les Adams | 25/03/1940 | 2nd XI | 1939/40 | R3S | C Grade | Wantirna | 2nd XI | Heathmont |
| J Benson | 18/10/1952 | 1st XI | 1952/53 | R02 | B Grade | Templestowe | 1st XI | Templestowe |
| Les Stoneham | 20/10/1956 | 1st XI | 1956/57 | R02 | B Grade | Box Hill Footballers | 1st XI | Warrandyte #1 |
| Allan Chapman | 26/01/1957 | 1st XI | 1956/57 | R08 | B Grade | Box Hill Footballers | 1st XI | Box Hill |
| Terry Leheny | 2/02/1963 | 1st XI | 1962/63 | R09 | B Grade | Mitcham | U | Mitcham |
| Alan Woolcock | 26/01/1970 | 1st XI | 1969/70 | R09 | A2 Grade | Nunawading | U | Warrandyte #1 |
| Robert White | 23/11/1974 | 1st XI | 1974/75 | R04 | A Grade | Blackburn C.O.C. | U | Domeney Reserve |
| Robert McDonald | 23/10/1976 | 1st XI | 1976/77 | R03 | B Grade | North Ringwood | 1st XI | North Ringwood |
| Steve Pascoe | 20/01/1979 | 1st XI | 1978/79 | R09 | A Grade | Heathmont Uniting | 1st XI | Warrandyte #1 |
| Steve Pascoe | 10/01/1981 | 1st XI | 1980/81 | R08 | Chandler 1 | North Ringwood | 1st XI | North Ringwood |
| Chris Snaidero | 1982 | U16 | 1981/82 | R? | ? | ? | ? | ? |
| Alan King | 5/11/1994 | 4th XI | 1994/95 | R03 | Chandler 4 | Croydon North | 4th XI | Barngeong No.1 |
| Peter Sharpe | 16/12/1995 | 4th XI | 1995/96 | R06 | Chandler 4 | Mooroolbark | 4th XI | Stintons Reserve |
| Steve Pascoe | 23/11/1996 | 3rd XI | 1996/97 | R05 | Chandler 3 | Norwood | 3rd XI | Mullum Res No.2 |
| John Prangley | 30/10/2004 | 3rd XI | 2004/05 | R04 | D Grade | North Ringwood | 4th XI | Stintons Reserve |
| Dean Gidley | 14/01/2006 | 3rd XI | 2005/06 | R10 | D Grade | Mooroolbark | 4th XI | Kiloran Reserve |
| Nathan Croft | 23/01/2010 | 4th XI | 2009/10 | R12 | H Grade | Boronia | 4th XI | Chandler Park |
| John Prangley | 18/12/2010 | 3rd XI | 2010/11 | R09 | D Grade | Heathmont Baptists | 2nd XI | Heathmont Reserve |
| Jarryd Lane | 29/01/2011 | 4th XI | 2010/11 | R12 | G Grade | Bayswater Park | 5th XI | Milperra Reserve |
| Jake Sherriff | 8/03/2015 | 1st XI | 2014/15 | QF | Wilkins | Kilsyth | 1st XI | Warrandyte #1 |
| Stephen Warr | 5/11/2016 | 4th XI | 2016/17 | R04 | F Grade | Lilydale | 4th XI | Gateway Reserve |
| Ethan Ward | 24/02/2018 | 3rd XI | 2017/18 | R14 | C Grade | Lilydale | 3rd XI | Gateway Reserve |
| Shaun Ison | 23/02/2019 | 4th XI | 2018/19 | R14 | C Grade | St Andrews | 5th XI | JW Manson Reserve No.3 |
| Max Gidley | 18/12/2020 | U12 | 2020/21 | R06 | G Grade | St Andrews | 2nd XI | Warrandyte Reserve No.2 |
